HR Glossary  /  Statutory Employee
Statutory Employee7 min read
Table of Contents:

What is a Statutory Employee?

The world of worker classification can be a complex one. You might be familiar with the standard categories: employee and independent contractor. But what about a worker who falls somewhere in between? Consider the concept of the statutory employee. These workers possess characteristics of both an employee and an independent contractor, resulting in a unique tax classification.

In this guide, we'll shed light on statutory employee meaning, their tax treatment, what is a statutory employee on W2, and the implications for both employers and workers.

Understanding Worker Classifications

Before we move on into statutory employees, let's establish the groundwork: Worker classification. Businesses can engage individuals in two primary categories: employees and independent contractors. The critical distinction hinges on control. Employees are subject to the company's control over what and how they perform their work. An independent contractor, in contrast, operates with more autonomy, offering their services with greater independence. Sometimes, working with an independent contractor involves a less substantial investment.

Misclassifying workers can lead to tax problems and penalties for both employers and employees. In order to avoid this, employers must keep in mind the three main factors the IRS considers before establishing worker classification:

  • Behavioral control: Does the company dictate the worker's schedule, methods, and tools?
  • Financial control: Who provides equipment and materials? Does the company reimburse expenses?
  • Relationship of the parties: Is there a long-term commitment or a one-off project? Does the company offer employee benefits?

Exempt vs Non-Exempt Employee: What is the Difference? →

A statutory employee occupies a particular space, blurring the lines between traditional employees and independent contractors. While technically self-employed, they receive special tax treatment from the IRS that incorporates aspects of both categories.

On the one hand, statutory employees often share characteristics with independent contractors. They may enjoy more control over their work schedule and methods compared to a regular employee. They might even use their own tools and equipment, and potentially have the freedom to work with other clients besides the company they're engaged with.

On the other hand, statutory employees are treated as employees for Social Security and Medicare tax purposes. This means both the employer and the employee contribute their respective share of these FICA taxes, similar to a traditional employee relationship. They also receive a W-2 form at the end of the year for tax filing purposes.

This unique tax treatment offers them some advantages. Like self-employed individuals, a statutory employee can deduct certain business expenses on their tax return using a Schedule C form. This allows them a wider range of deductible expenses compared to regular employees who use a Schedule A form. But let’s not rush, we’ll take a deeper look into statutory employees’ advantages in the following sections.

In simpler terms, a statutory employee gets a taste of the tax benefits associated with self-employment while also experiencing simplified payroll tax withholding like regular employees. However, it's important to remember that they typically don't receive traditional employee benefits like health insurance or paid time off.

We’ve already seen what statutory employee translates into. So, who qualifies for this unique designation? There are four main categories of statutory employees:

  1. Delivery drivers: This includes drivers who distribute specific goods like beverages, bakery items, or laundry/dry cleaning services. The key factors are being an agent of the company or receiving commission-based pay.
  2. Life insurance sales agents: These are full-time agents who primarily sell policies for one specific life insurance company. One life insurance company can contract with a city salesperson selling life insurance… and that person could just be paid like a contractor but with certain employee protections. The salesperson's principal business activity is still selling life insurance for their contracting company—very similar to what it would be if the person were a full-time employee.
  3. Home-based workers: Those who work from home, but using materials supplied by the company, and that are required to follow certain work specifications. The materials must be returned to the company upon completion of the work.
  4. Salespeople: Full-time traveling or city salespeople who work on behalf of a company, securing orders from wholesalers, retailers, or various establishments, can qualify as a statutory employee. The key points are selling merchandise for resale or business supplies, and this activity being their principal business activity.

For all these categories, three additional conditions must be met to be considered a statutory employee:

  • Personal service: The service contract implies that the worker will perform most of the services themselves.
  • Limited investment: The worker doesn't have a significant investment in the equipment or property used for the job (excluding transportation).
  • Continuing work: The services are performed consistently for the same employer, almost like common law employees.

As we’ve been saying, a statutory employee occupies a unique middle ground between an independent contractor and a traditional employee. This means their benefits picture is different from both categories. Let’s see how:

Benefits for Statutory Employees

  • Simplified tax withholding: Unlike independent contractors, employers withhold FICA taxes from statutory employee wages—which simplifies tax filing for both parties. It's a well-established way to stay out of a tax liability.
  • Reduced self-employment tax burden: A statutory employee isn’t subject to the full self-employment tax that independent contractors pay.
  • Expanded expense deductions: Similar to self-employed individuals, a statutory employee can deduct certain business expenses on their tax return using a Schedule C form. This allows for a wider range of deductible expenses compared to regular employees using a Schedule A form.

What Statutory Employees Typically Don't Receive

Unlike regular employees, statutory employees generally don't enjoy the comprehensive benefits package typically offered by companies. They are not eligible for benefits such as health insurance, retirement plans, PTO, or other fringe benefits like employee discounts and tuition reimbursement.

How Effective Time Off Policies Can Improve Employee Attendance →

We've covered the common statutory employee categories like life insurance salespeople, home-based workers with supplied materials, and delivery drivers. But the world of statutory employees extends beyond these. Let's take a look at some lesser-known statutory employee examples:

  • Freelance writers/editors: You can think of a freelance writer who works for a specific online publication. If a writer is required to follow the publication's style guide and editorial calendar, and receives most of her income from them, there's a chance she could be considered a statutory employee.
  • Contractors providing ongoing services: A plumber can have a long-term contract with a property management company to handle all their plumbing needs. While the plumber might seem like a typical independent contractor, if they don't have a significant investment in specialized equipment and works exclusively for this company, they might qualify as a statutory employee.
  • Musicians in a touring band: The members of a band that performs regularly for a particular music venue could potentially be statutory employees. This would depend on factors like the level of control the venue has over their performances and if the band primarily performs there. But, let's say, a house band performing with a circus company—they could well be statutory employees.

These are just a few examples, and the specific details of the work arrangement are of great importance. Consulting a tax professional for specific situations is always a smart move.

Statutory employees receive a W-2 form (also known as W2 form; these terms are used interchangeably) just like regular employees, typically at the end of January. This form is required for filing their annual tax return. However, there's a key difference: Box 13 on the W-2 for a statutory employee will be checked to indicate their special tax status.

Understanding the W-2

The W-2 form summarizes your wages and withheld taxes for the tax year. Here's a breakdown of the relevant sections for a statutory employee:

  • Box 1 (wages, tips, other compensation): This box shows the total amount of taxable income you earned from your employer during the year.
  • Box 5 (federal income tax withheld): This amount reflects the federal income taxes your employer withheld from your paychecks throughout the year.
  • Box 13 (social security or railroad retirement tax withheld): This box indicates the Social Security taxes withheld by your employer. Unlike independent contractors, a statutory employee has these taxes withheld from their pay.
  • Box 14 (medicare tax withheld): This box shows the Medicare tax withheld by your employer.

Tax Filing for Statutory Employees

While receiving a W-2 simplifies tax filing compared to independent contractors, there's an additional step for statutory employees. Since they can deduct certain business expenses, they have the option to file a Schedule C form alongside their regular tax return.

Schedule C and Business Expense Deductions

  • Schedule C: This form allows a statutory employee to report their business income and expenses.
  • Business expense deductions: Similar to self-employed individuals, a statutory employee can deduct ordinary and necessary business expenses related to their work. Examples include mileage from business travel, office supplies, or equipment depreciation. However, unlike a Schedule A used by regular employees, the deductions on a Schedule C aren't subject to the 2% adjusted-gross-income threshold. This can offer significant tax savings for statutory employees with qualifying business expenses.

What are the tax implications for hiring a statutory employee?

As an employer, you're responsible for withholding and paying the employer's share of Social Security and Medicare taxes for a statutory employee. You'll report these taxes along with their wages on their W-2 form (marked with “Statutory Employee” in Box 13). You don't withhold federal income tax, but you'll still need to file Form 941 for quarterly tax reporting.

Are statutory employees eligible for unemployment benefits?

In certain circumstances, a statutory employee might be eligible for unemployment insurance. However, the eligibility for unemployment benefits for statutory employees varies by state. Consider implementing HR software solutions like TalentHR for effective employment and benefits management.

How do statutory employees impact payroll processing?

Payroll processing for a statutory employee is similar to regular employees in that you'll withhold FICA taxes. However, you won't withhold federal income tax. It's important to update your payroll system to reflect their classification and ensure proper tax withholding and reporting.

What are the advantages of hiring statutory employees?

There are several advantages to hiring statutory employees:

  • Cost savings: You avoid the full employer payroll taxes you'd pay for regular employees.
  • Flexibility: Statutory employees often offer more flexible work arrangements compared to full-time staff.
  • Access to specialized skills: You can tap into the expertise of independent contractors while simplifying tax withholding for specific tasks.

Cut the clutter in HR tasks, and grow
your business faster